Casey Key Real Estate

Casey Key Real Estate for Sale

Discover all Casey Key real estate listings here!

Casey Key is a hidden gem on a narrow, 8-mile long barrier island on Florida’s west coast. Nestled between Siesta Key and Venice, this exclusive community holds some of the most spectacular homes in the Sarasota area, and offers stunning views of the Gulf and Sarasota Bay. An abundance of palm, pine, oak and mangrove trees along the only road that stretches from one end of Casey Key to the other creates a private and secluded atmosphere. With only about 500 residents and no high rise condominiums or sprawling resorts, the quiet and laidback lifestyle found in Casey Key is a draw to many.


Start browsing our Casey Key real estate listings below or learn why homes for sale in Casey Key could be perfect for you!

Casey Key May 18, 2024
Avg. DOM
Avg. $ / Sq.Ft.
Med. List Price
24 Properties
Page 1 of 2

Be the FIRST to see new Casey Key real estate listings!

Register with Key Solutions Real Estate Group and gain free, instant access to exclusive search tools.
Create custom searches, bookmark your favorite listings and get email alerts as soon as Casey Key homes for sale matching your dream criteria hit the market.

Register With Us

Casey Key Real Estate Market

Casey Key real estate is primarily made up of quaint beach cottages and contemporary estates with sandy beaches, secluded wooded lots and spectacular views. Homes located on narrower parts of the island have views of both the Gulf and the bay, and private access to both. Estates here often feature Mediterranean style architecture, with only the most upscale designs and every kind of amenity you can imagine. With such natural beauty and seclusion, it’s no wonder that Casey Key real estate is so highly-sought after, and has an average listing price of over $3.5 million dollars. 

casey key beach

Casey Key Highlights

  • Private & secluded lots
  • Waterfront/beachfront homes
  • Spectacular Gulf & Sarasota Bay views
  • Private beach access & boat slips
  • Short drive to Venice & Sarasota

The Casey Key Lifestyle

As an owner of Casey Key real estate, you can enjoy whichever outdoor activities you like thanks to your private beachfront. You can also visit one of the two public beaches located at the south end of Casey Key, Nokomis Beach and North Jetty Beach. You’ll find everything you need and more in Nokomis, without ever being far from the sparkling water of the Gulf of Mexico. Whether you’re walking the boardwalk or using the boat launch facilities for a day on the water, there’s no better way to end the day than to eat seafood at one of the local waterfront bars.

Have questions about Casey Key real estate?

The team at Key Solutions Real Estate Group can help you with all of your Sarasota real estate needs. Send us a message or call us at (941) 894-1255 for more information about Casey Key homes for sale!

Contact Us

^ Back to Casey Key